Skip to Main Content
MCCARTHYS PUB NYC logo topMCCARTHYS PUB NYC logo scroll
  • Twitter pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Catering
  • Parties
  • Order
  • About Us

Our Menu

MealsButlered Hors D’OeuvresBuffet MenuSit Down Dinner MenuOpen Bar Packages

Consuming raw or undercooked meats may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Apps & Taps

House Made Potato Chips

$8.00
Cajun seasoned, ranch dip.
French Onion Soup photo

French Onion Soup

$9.00
Crouton, Swiss cheese.
Irish Cocktail Sausages photo

Irish Cocktail Sausages

$15.00
Curry, mayonnaise, crouton, Swiss cheese.

Chips & Guac

$12.00
House-made guacamole & tomato salsa, tortilla chips.

Giant Beer Pretzel

$14.00
Drunken cheese sauce.

Chicken Wings

$16.00
(8) Wings, Buffalo, Barbecue or Sweet Chili Sauce, celery & carrots, blue cheese.
Spinach & Artichoke Dip photo

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

$17.00
Blackened pita chips.

Shrimp Dumplings

$15.00
Soy & sweet chili dipping sauce.

Cheeseburger Sliders

$16.00
Four Angus burgers, American cheese, cajun potato chips, ranch dip.

Classic Margherita Flatbread

$15.00
Fresh mozzarella cheese, chunky tomato sauce, micro basil.

Buffalo Cauliflower Flatbread

$16.00
Roasted cauliflower, hot sauce, scallions, blue cheese drizzle.

Mini Chicken Cordon Bleu

$14.00
Chipotle aioli.

Chicken Quesadilla

$16.00
Chicken, peppers, onion, cheddar cheese, flour tortilla, salsa, guacamole, & sour cream.

Breaded Cheese Bites

$14.00
Marinara sauce.

Calamari

$17.00
Crispy calamari, parmesan cheese, shallots, fried jalapenos, & marinara sauce.
McCarthy's Beef Nachos photo

McCarthy's Beef Nachos

$18.00
Tortilla chips, homemade beef chili, cheddar cheese, jalapeños, tomato, onion, sour cream, guacamole, & salsa | Vegetarian also available | Add Chicken +$6.00

Irish Favorites

Irish Beef Stew photo

Irish Beef Stew

$22.00
Braised hanger steak, mashed potatoes, roasted parsnips & carrots, red wine reduction.
Shepherd's Pie photo

Shepherd's Pie

$22.00
Ground Angus beef, carrots & peas, gravy, mashed potatoes.

Fish & Chips

$21.00
Beer battered cod fish, tartar sauce, hand cut fries.
Bangers & Mash photo

Bangers & Mash

$22.00
Irish jumbo sausage topped with crispy onions & gravy, served with mashed potatoes.

Irish Chicken Curry

$24.00
Sliced chicken, peppers, onions, broccoli, mushrooms, & green beans in McDonnell's Irish curry sauce with fries & rice.

McCarthy's Sirloin

$38.00
12oz Angus NY sirloin, caramelized onions, fried mushroom, roasted potatoes in a Jameson Irish whiskey sauce.

Salads

Add: Chicken +$6.00 or Shrimp +$9.00

Garden Salad

$10.00
Mixed baby greens, diced onion, grape tomato, shredded carrots, & ranch dressing.
The Chopped Cobb photo

The Chopped Cobb

$20.00
Grilled chicken, bacon, red onion, hardboiled egg, avocado, tomatoes, crumbled blue cheese, romaine lettuce, & blue cheese dressing.
Filet Mignon Steak Salad* photo

Filet Mignon Steak Salad*

$24.00
Marinated sliced Angus filet mignon, mixed baby greens, grilled red onion, roasted cherry tomatoes, & balsamic dressing.

Caesar Salad

$16.00
Crisp romaine lettuce, brioche croutons, shaved parmesan, & caesar dressing.

Burger & Sandwiches

Angus Burger*

$18.00
8oz grass-fed Angus burger, lettuce, tomato, onion, seeded bun, hand cut fries.
McCarthy's Signature Burger* photo

McCarthy's Signature Burger*

$23.00
8oz grass-fed Angus burger, blue cheese, house pickles, crispy onions, & smoked bacon, McCarthy's sauce, brioche bun, hand cut fries.

Gaelic Burger*

$22.00
8oz grass-fed Angus burger, Irish bacon, sautéed onion, sharp cheddar cheese, seeded bun, hand cut fries.
Texas BBQ Burger* photo

Texas BBQ Burger*

$22.00
8oz grass-fed Angus burger, pepper-jack cheese, bacon, frizzled onions, bbq sauce, seeded bun, hand cut fries.

Beyond Burger

$20.00
Guacamole, chipotle mayo, lettuce, red onion, tomato, on multigrain bread, side salad.

Filet Mignon Steak Sandwich*

$24.00
6oz sliced Angus filet, sauteed onions & mushrooms, swiss cheese, horseradish creme, baguette, hand cut fries.
Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich photo

Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich

$22.00
Crispy fried chicken, market greens, chipotle mayo, house pickles, on a brioche roll, McCarthy's potato chips.

Corned Beef Panini

$19.00
Sliced Irish corned beef, braised cabbage, Dijon mustard, Swiss cheese, sweet potato fries.

Cheese, Tomato, & Onion Panini

$17.00
Sharp cheddar cheese, sliced tomato, red onion, on white bread, hand cut fries.

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$19.00
Crispy chicken tossed in hot sauce, lettuce, tomato, blue cheese dressing in a grilled tortilla wrap, McCarthy's potato chips.

Entrees

Add: Grilled Chicken +$6.00 | Grilled Shrimp +$9.00

Chicken Breast photo

Chicken Breast

$24.00
Pan roasted chicken breast, roasted garlic & herb sauce, crusted potato, & sauteed broccoli.
Atlantic Salmon photo

Atlantic Salmon

$26.00
Atlantic salmon, capers, tomatoes in a lime butter sauce, rice, & spinach.
Rigatoni Pasta photo

Rigatoni Pasta

$22.00
Fresh rigatoni, grilled zucchini, spinach, roasted grape tomatoes, roasted garlic sauce.

Lobster Ravioli

$28.00
Maine lobster ravioli topped in a creamy vodka sauce, toasted garlic bread.

Penne a la Vodka

$18.00
Penne pasta in a creamy pink vodka sauce, Reggiano cheese.

Sides

Truffle Fries

$12.00
Parmesan, shallots, truffle oil.

McCarthy's Fries

$9.00

Sweet Potato Fries

$9.00

Beer Battered Onion Rings

$9.00

Mashed Potatoes

$8.00

Irish Curry Sauce

$6.00

Chefs Vegetables

$8.00

Desserts

Chocolate Lava Cake

$12.00
Hershey's chocolate sauce, vanilla ice cream.

New York Style Cheesecake

$10.00
Baked cheesecake, berry coulis, cream.

Sticky Toffee Pudding

$12.00
Served warm, caramel sauce, ice cream.

Apple Blossom

$12.00
Served warm, caramel sauce, ice cream.

Vanilla Ice Cream Sundae

$8.00
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce.

Choose 5 | $45.00 per person

Cold

Prosciutto Wrapped Melon

Smoked Salmon

Pumpernickel, creme fraiche.

Shrimp Cocktail

Cocktail sauce

Jumbo Lump Crab Salad

Served on toast.

Tuna Poke

Daikon radish, spicy aioli.

Boursin Crostini

Fig and black olive tapenade.

Hot

Bacon Wrapped Scallops

Spicy mayo

Fried Avocado

Sriracha aioli

Sliders

Crab, beef, chicken.

Lamb Lollipops

Chimichurri

Toasted Points NY

Strip, horseradish cream.

Coconut Shrimp

Sweet and sour mango sauce.

Crispy Gallete

Fig marmalade, blue cheese.

Salads choose 2, Entrees choose 3 | $60.00 per person | Accompaniments: Seasonal Vegetables, Parmesan Roasted Pee-Wee Potatoes, or Saffron Rice

Menu

Caesar Salad

Brioche croutons, grated parmesan.

Mixed Greens

Cranberry, slivered almonds, goat cheese.

B.L.T

Romaine, bacon, tomato, blue cheese.

Chicken Marsala

Wild mushrooms, marsala sauce.

Roasted Airline Chicken

Orzo, artichokes, olives, tomato.

Sliced Skirt Steak

Chimichurri

Roast Beef

Au Jus

Salmon

Mustard, pineapple glazed.

Baked Shrimp

Lemon garlic broth.

Penne

Seasonal vegetables.

Penne Arabiatta

Spicy tomato, parmesan.

$60.00 per person

Appetizer

Bruschetta

Salad

Mixed Green Salad

Entree

Choose 1:

Airline Chicken

Orzo, artichokes, olives, tomato.

Sliced Skirt Steak

Chimichurri, mashed potato.

Salmon

Coconut ginger rice, swiss chard, mango salsa.

Penne

Seasonal vegetables.

Dessert

Chocolate Cake

All packages exclude single malt scotch, shots, & champagne.

Menu

Tier 1

$60.00/+
Imported & domestic beer, premium liquor, wines, soda, juice, tea, & coffee • 2 hours $60.00 per person | 3 hours $70.00 per person

Tier 2

$55.00/+
Imported & domestic beer, call liquor, select wines, soda, juice, tea, & coffee • 2 hours $55.00 per person | 3 hours $65.00 per person

Tier 3

$50.00/+
Domestic beer, house liquor, select wines, soda, juice, tea, & coffee • 2 hours $50.00 per person | 3 hours $60.00 per person

Tier 4

$43.00/+
Domestic beer, select wines, soda, juice, tea, & coffee • 2 hours $43.00 per person | 3 hours $53.00 per person
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering